Graph Algorithms Hard problems

K Centers Problem | Set 1 (Greedy Approximate Algorithm)

K Centers Problem - Greedy Approximate Algorithm - Let OPT be the maximum distance of a city from a center in the Optimal solution. We need to show that

K Centers Problem | Set 1 (Greedy Approximate Algorithm) – learn in 30 sec from microsoft awarded MVPFor example consider the following four cities, 0, 1, 2 and 3 and distances between them, how do place 2 ATMs among these 4 cities so that the maximum distance of a city to an ATM is minimized.

There is no polynomial time solution available for this problem as the problem is a known NP-Hard problem. There is a polynomial time Greedy approximate algorithm, the greedy algorithm provides a solution which is never worse that twice the optimal solution. The greedy solution works only if the distances between cities follow Triangular Inequality (Distance between two points is always smaller than sum of distances through a third point).

The 2-Approximate Greedy Algorithm:
1) Choose the first center arbitrarily.

2) Choose remaining k-1 centers using the following criteria.
Let c1, c2, c3, … ci be the already chosen centers. Choose
(i+1)’th center by picking the city which is farthest from already
selected centers, i.e, the point p which has following value as maximum
Min[dist(p, c1), dist(p, c2), dist(p, c3), …. dist(p, ci)]

Example (k = 3 in the above shown Graph)
a) Let the first arbitrarily picked vertex be 0.

b) The next vertex is 1 because 1 is the farthest vertex from 0.

c) Remaining cities are 2 and 3. Calculate their distances from already selected centers (0 and 1). The greedy algorithm basically calculates following values.

Minimum of all distanced from 2 to already considered centers
Min[dist(2, 0), dist(2, 1)] = Min[7, 8] = 7

Minimum of all distanced from 3 to already considered centers
Min[dist(3, 0), dist(3, 1)] = Min[6, 5] = 5

READ  Java algorithm - Breadth First Traversal or BFS for a Graph

After computing the above values, the city 2 is picked as the value corresponding to 2 is maximum.

Note that the greedy algorithm doesn’t give best solution for k = 2 as this is just an approximate algorithm with bound as twice of optimal.

Proof that the above greedy algorithm is 2 approximate.
Let OPT be the maximum distance of a city from a center in the Optimal solution. We need to show that the maximum distance obtained from Greedy algorithm is 2*OPT.

The proof can be done using contradiction.

a) Assume that the distance from the furthest point to all centers is > 2·OPT.

b) This means that distances between all centers are also > 2·OPT.

c) We have k + 1 points with distances > 2·OPT between every pair.

d) Each point has a center of the optimal solution with distance <= OPT to it.

e) There exists a pair of points with the same center X in the optimal solution (pigeonhole principle: k optimal centers, k+1 points)

f) The distance between them is at most 2·OPT (triangle inequality) which is a contradiction.

About the author

Venkatesan Prabu

Venkatesan Prabu

Wikitechy Founder, Author, International Speaker, and Job Consultant. My role as the CEO of Wikitechy, I help businesses build their next generation digital platforms and help with their product innovation and growth strategy. I'm a frequent speaker at tech conferences and events.